FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $60... BECAUSE YOU'RE AWESOME! FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $120... BECAUSE YOU'RE AWESOME! FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $60 FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $120
MAKE IT MATCHY-MATCHY!

Which Witch? Brooch

Afterpay sezzle-icon
available
FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING AUSTRALIA WIDE > $60
FREE STANDARD INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING > $120
FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING AUSTRALIA WIDE > $60
FREE STANDARD INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING > $120

Abracadabra, Halloween night, let's do a spell to show us a sprite! With beautiful solid resins, featuring hand-painted and hand-assembled details she's got a spark in her eye and a magic smile. There's nothing more magic than a new friend, and she's got all the witchcraft you need! 

STORY

Come, sit for a spell. There is plenty of room on the broom. Let me take away all your gloom.

INFO

Original Designer Stephanie Buscema

Height 70 mm x Width 40.4 mm

Each piece is hand assembled, hand painted and released in limited quantities. All designs are made from layered resin. As designs are produced from original illustrations and are hand assembled, hand painted and hand finished, there may be minor differences from piece to piece, making each as unique as those who wear them. Metal components used in creating this piece include a beautiful and strong silver-plated steel brooch pin. Any earring posts, earring hooks, necklace chains and jump rings used for this piece are made from silver-plated steel.

Designs come packaged in Erstwilder gift boxes.

CARE

Please be aware that resin is akin to ceramic and glass and therefore may be damaged if dropped or knocked. Due to the use of high-quality silver-plating in our brooch clasps, tarnishing and oxidisation can occur, producing a black and gold discolouration. As with all silver products, you can simply restore it using a silver cloth. Keep your Erstwilder companion neatly tucked away in this box when not being worn, avoid contact with perfumes, lotions, water, and excessive sunlight and you'll have a trusted friend for years to come.

Customer Reviews

Based on 14 reviews
100%
(14)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
T
Tracey S. (London, GB)
Rather wonderful

This brooch is rather wonderful, she has so much character, I can’t wait to wear her. Love the packaging the brooches arrived in, not only did the contents out a smile on my face but so did the quirky writing on the box, thanks Erstwilder all round fantastic.

S
Sally (Forster, AU)
Which witch?

Wasn’t exactly sold on this brooch until I saw it in person, and it is gorgeous! So glad that I added this one to my growing collection. When they say a picture tells a thousand words, I disagree! Reality is far more beautiful. Erstwilder you’ve done it again 🥰🧙🏻

J
Janet L. (Sydney, AU)
Which Witch Brooch

I chose it for my friend Aster's birthday as she loves the colour purple and it suited her personality. She was so excited to receive it as I had gifted the purple poppy a few days before while I waited for the witch. She pictured them all together and posted the badges box and all for envious family and friends to enjoy.

l
laura c. (Monroeville, US)
I Love These Brooches

I have worn pins on jacket and sweater lapels for years. I prefer 1940s galalithe and Bakelite to most contemporary things for their style and whimsey so I was really excited to stumble upon Erstwilder brooches. They are charming and unique. The colors of resin and attention to detail in the design is what separates them from other contemporary jewelry makers. My sole complaint is the quality of the pin back/finding itself: The little keepers/catchers often snap off by the fourth or fifth wear; sometimes on the first. The special edition brooches for holidays are among my favorites since, as a teacher, I can wear funky stuff and no one thinks I am unprofessional, merely eccentric. I also like the Pete Cromer collaborations because they are true to a particular artistic vision and are generally animals I have never seen in NYC. Of all the things Erstwilder makes, however, the cardie clips are the most fun and garner the most comments from students and colleagues. Considering I have severely depleted my retirement saving on the last two launches (Cromer/Christmas and Peanuts) I think I must by now qualify as totally addicted.

D
Deborah H. (Riverside, US)
Which Witch is Perfect

I went back a week or so after the release to buy Which Witch because I really regretted not getting her with my initial purchase. I am thrilled with how cute she is. She completes my Kitchen Witch collection and I will treasure her always.

1 2 3
MAKE IT MATCHY-MATCHY!

Customer Reviews

Based on 14 reviews
100%
(14)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
T
Tracey S. (London, GB)
Rather wonderful

This brooch is rather wonderful, she has so much character, I can’t wait to wear her. Love the packaging the brooches arrived in, not only did the contents out a smile on my face but so did the quirky writing on the box, thanks Erstwilder all round fantastic.

S
Sally (Forster, AU)
Which witch?

Wasn’t exactly sold on this brooch until I saw it in person, and it is gorgeous! So glad that I added this one to my growing collection. When they say a picture tells a thousand words, I disagree! Reality is far more beautiful. Erstwilder you’ve done it again 🥰🧙🏻

J
Janet L. (Sydney, AU)
Which Witch Brooch

I chose it for my friend Aster's birthday as she loves the colour purple and it suited her personality. She was so excited to receive it as I had gifted the purple poppy a few days before while I waited for the witch. She pictured them all together and posted the badges box and all for envious family and friends to enjoy.

l
laura c. (Monroeville, US)
I Love These Brooches

I have worn pins on jacket and sweater lapels for years. I prefer 1940s galalithe and Bakelite to most contemporary things for their style and whimsey so I was really excited to stumble upon Erstwilder brooches. They are charming and unique. The colors of resin and attention to detail in the design is what separates them from other contemporary jewelry makers. My sole complaint is the quality of the pin back/finding itself: The little keepers/catchers often snap off by the fourth or fifth wear; sometimes on the first. The special edition brooches for holidays are among my favorites since, as a teacher, I can wear funky stuff and no one thinks I am unprofessional, merely eccentric. I also like the Pete Cromer collaborations because they are true to a particular artistic vision and are generally animals I have never seen in NYC. Of all the things Erstwilder makes, however, the cardie clips are the most fun and garner the most comments from students and colleagues. Considering I have severely depleted my retirement saving on the last two launches (Cromer/Christmas and Peanuts) I think I must by now qualify as totally addicted.

D
Deborah H. (Riverside, US)
Which Witch is Perfect

I went back a week or so after the release to buy Which Witch because I really regretted not getting her with my initial purchase. I am thrilled with how cute she is. She completes my Kitchen Witch collection and I will treasure her always.

1 2 3
★ Judge.me Reviews

Let customers speak for us

25685 reviews
96%
(24669)
3%
(656)
1%
(207)
0%
(88)
0%
(65)
M
Owl Eyes on You Brooch
Marte O.J. (Oslo, NO)
Beautiful! 😍

This little treasure is absolutely stunning! I love it and make sure to wear it as often as I possibly can, seeing as it's already become one of my all time favourites! The colours are amazing, but it's the cute little owl face on this brooch that does it for me.

M
Alice Down the Rabbit Hole Brooch
Marte O.J. (Oslo, NO)
Love it! ❤

I’m a huge fan of Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, and so naturally this was a “must have” for me when I first saw it. This brooch is breathtakingly beautiful and I’ve loved it since I received it! The colours are stunning and I like the small details, like her stockings, which gives this Alice-brooch life.
It’s clear that a lot of love and care were put into the creation of this amazing brooch and the team should be extremely proud of themselves for making this gem. Shipping was, as usual, fast and the gift box it came in was lovely.

I adore it and it’s definitely become one of my all time favourites! Love it! ❤ Thank you for making this beauty!

C
Painted Rose Brooch
Courtney S. (Vancouver, CA)
Don't lose your head!

A perfectly painted red rose! Gorgeous layers of colour, such amazing vintage shape!

S
Taming Tamara Brooch
Sarah M. (Manchester, GB)
Breath-taking, bewildering, beautiful brooches

I bought 3 brooches in the black friday sale and had to wait because I livein the UK. Well they were worth wait! They exceeded all of my expectations. And the customer service was excellent, the staff made me feel at ease when I thought my brooches were stick on Melbourne 🤣 just wonderful staff and such beautiful brooches

N
Poppy Field Card Holder
Nicky A. (Sydney, AU)
Don't mean to brag

I've got the bag so how could I resist the matching card holder - couldn't, so didn't.
This I bought as my birthday present. So Lovley

1 2 3