FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $60... BECAUSE YOU'RE AWESOME! FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $120... BECAUSE YOU'RE AWESOME! FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $60 FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $120
MAKE IT MATCHY-MATCHY!

What's Your Poison? Brooch

Afterpay sezzle-icon
available
FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING AUSTRALIA WIDE > $60
FREE STANDARD INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING > $120
FREE EXPRESS SHIPPING AUSTRALIA WIDE > $60
FREE STANDARD INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING > $120

Please note each piece may differ from one to another, and to the 'What's Your Poison' brooch pictured. The design features a collection of beautiful marbled and textured resins which can differ from piece to piece. Because of this each brooch will be unique, making your pieces special and one of a kind. 

This isn't any old spell, this potion will make you fall in love with every brooch you see. With a collection of marbled and textured resin, with beautiful hand-painted details this stand-out design is also featured on the 'What's your Poison?" Necklace. Go for a matchy matchy, witchy vibe and pair the two together, you'll be irresistible!  

STORY

Don’t you love a liquid spell? We’ve got them all, ready to sell. So what’s your poison? Please do tell.

INFO

Original Designer Carmen Hui

Height 71 mm x Width 55 mm

Designs come packaged in Erstwilder gift boxes.

Each piece is made from laser cut and layered resin, hand assembled, hand painted and released in limited quantities. As all of our designs are lovingly glued, assembled and painted by hand there can be finger print marks and very slight variations and blemishes from piece to piece. Due to the hand mixed nature of the resins in our designs it is also common and normal to find tiny flecks or bubbles in the resin layers. All in all this just makes each piece as special and unique as you are.

Brooch clasps, necklace chains and jump rings are made from silver-plated steel. Earrings hooks and posts are made from high quality, hypoallergenic stainless steel.

CARE

Please be aware that resin is akin to ceramic and glass and therefore may be damaged if dropped or knocked. Due to the use of high quality silver-plating in our brooch clasps, tarnishing and oxidisation can occur, producing black and gold discolouration. As with all silver products, you can simply restore it using a silver cloth. Keep your Erstwilder companion neatly tucked away in this box when not being worn, avoid contact with perfumes, lotions, water and excessive sunlight and you’ll have a trusted friend for years to come.

Customer Reviews

Based on 11 reviews
91%
(10)
9%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
S
Stephanie G. (Perth, AU)
Cute spooky design

I adore this brooch, I love to pair it with my Raven Mad necklace. The beautiful colours and style give me halloween vibes all year round.

L
Lori A. (San Francisco, US)
potion brooch

Friends LOVED the brooch. received raved reviews.

C
Cara N. (Melbourne, AU)
A fair review

I love this brooch. A great design. I love the colours. Not ones I would usually choose. Colours that add colour and spice to an everyday and normally mundane look. There's a little witch in all of us. But what is her poison? I think it's empty. Just a warning to the wise that she is dangerous and capable. The size is perfection. The clasp is a little difficult to close which I understand is necessary. I would like to offer a suggestion. I want to wear this with lots of clothing but don't want to ruin the fabric. I would suggest that if you have spent over $100 you can have the option to add a magna pin to your order free of charge. I know this would be of great use to me

C
Cheyenne (Albuquerque, US)
Love it!

I've only recently discovered Erstwilder and it is dangerous! This is such a gorgeous brooch with beautiful coloring and beautifully made. This was my second brooch made by Erstwilder and I have added six more since then! I guess Erstwilder brooches are my poison...in a good way.

Z
Zoe (Sydney, AU)
Lovely all-round service

I purchases a 'What's your poison' brooch and a pair of black bunny earrings; they are very cute and look just like what I expected. I also had a lucky dip brooch, and I was expecting to get a brooch I wasn't too keen on and not my style, but they hand picked it to match what I had bought, and ended up with a Poe Raven brooch, which I love so much! I had a hand written message that says 'You are wonderful xxxx' and it was packed so neatly and delicately. I now have a few brooches, and am looking forward to adding more to my collection! Nothing about purchasing from you guys is a bad experience, I love this store!

1 2 3
MAKE IT MATCHY-MATCHY!

Customer Reviews

Based on 11 reviews
91%
(10)
9%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
S
Stephanie G. (Perth, AU)
Cute spooky design

I adore this brooch, I love to pair it with my Raven Mad necklace. The beautiful colours and style give me halloween vibes all year round.

L
Lori A. (San Francisco, US)
potion brooch

Friends LOVED the brooch. received raved reviews.

C
Cara N. (Melbourne, AU)
A fair review

I love this brooch. A great design. I love the colours. Not ones I would usually choose. Colours that add colour and spice to an everyday and normally mundane look. There's a little witch in all of us. But what is her poison? I think it's empty. Just a warning to the wise that she is dangerous and capable. The size is perfection. The clasp is a little difficult to close which I understand is necessary. I would like to offer a suggestion. I want to wear this with lots of clothing but don't want to ruin the fabric. I would suggest that if you have spent over $100 you can have the option to add a magna pin to your order free of charge. I know this would be of great use to me

C
Cheyenne (Albuquerque, US)
Love it!

I've only recently discovered Erstwilder and it is dangerous! This is such a gorgeous brooch with beautiful coloring and beautifully made. This was my second brooch made by Erstwilder and I have added six more since then! I guess Erstwilder brooches are my poison...in a good way.

Z
Zoe (Sydney, AU)
Lovely all-round service

I purchases a 'What's your poison' brooch and a pair of black bunny earrings; they are very cute and look just like what I expected. I also had a lucky dip brooch, and I was expecting to get a brooch I wasn't too keen on and not my style, but they hand picked it to match what I had bought, and ended up with a Poe Raven brooch, which I love so much! I had a hand written message that says 'You are wonderful xxxx' and it was packed so neatly and delicately. I now have a few brooches, and am looking forward to adding more to my collection! Nothing about purchasing from you guys is a bad experience, I love this store!

1 2 3
★ Judge.me Reviews

Let customers speak for us

25710 reviews
96%
(24693)
3%
(657)
1%
(207)
0%
(88)
0%
(65)
B
Lucky Dip Brooch
Britt C. (Adelaide, AU)
I got lucky!

I was very excited to receive a lucky dip exclusive as one of my lucky dips. Will I be so lucky next time? I guess it’s up to last luck!

V
Saltwater Wisdom Earrings
Virginie L. (Sydney, AU)
Beautifully crafted earrings!

Communications from Erstwilder was lovely and timely. Packaging from Erstwilder is always delightful, beautiful boxes, beautiful wrapping. It makes all orders very special and precious. The earrings themselves, as all accessories I have ordered, are beautifully crafted, lovely vibrant pink colour and adorable shiny pearl. Super cute!

J
Fruit Salad Strawberry Enamel Pin
Jayvbee (Point Cook, AU)
Paris Collection.

Another most delightful set of pins. So typically all things Parisian. The girl in the beret and the poodle are my favourites, though the Eiffel Tower is well up there too. Have had to get another box to store them in.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

E
Knave of Hearts Brooch
Elizabeth R. (Abbotsford, CA)
Such a sweetie 💕

I love this young man. 💕 He makes me laugh!

L
Pinky Promise Earrings
Lara D. (Sydney, AU)
Gorgeous

Love the detail, I've had many compliments while wearing these.

1 2 3